★ 5.0 on Google (17 reviews)  |  Serving Central & Southeastern PA  |  Call 717-864-6896 for a Free Estimate
Full siding replacement

Siding Replacement: James Hardie or Premium Vinyl

Fortress Siding & Roofing replaces siding on homes across ten Pennsylvania counties from our base in Mountville, Lancaster County. A full replacement means the old siding comes off, the wall behind it is inspected, and new James Hardie fiber cement or premium vinyl goes on over a proper weather barrier. Our siding work carries a 10-year workmanship guarantee from Fortress.

PA HIC #PA203681Fully insuredFree, detailed estimatesWe handle the permits

What does a full siding replacement include?

A full siding replacement includes removing the old siding, inspecting the wall sheathing, installing the weather-resistive barrier and flashing, installing the new siding and trim, and cleanup. Siding is not the water barrier, so the layers behind it matter as much as the boards you see.

If we find rot once the old siding is off, you see it and approve the repair before we go further. We handle the permits.

Should you choose James Hardie or premium vinyl?

Both are sound choices, and the house and the budget usually decide. James Hardie fiber cement is our specialty; premium vinyl is the lower-cost route.

James Hardie fiber cement and premium vinyl compared
James Hardie fiber cementPremium vinyl
MaterialPortland cement, sand, cellulose fibers and waterPVC panels
Up-front costHigherLower
LookWide trim and deep shadow lines, close to painted woodClean, low-maintenance lines
Best fitCharacter homes such as Cape Cods, Colonials and TudorsHomes where budget leads the decision
Read moreJames Hardie sidingPremium vinyl siding

Our comparison of James Hardie and vinyl siding for Pennsylvania homes goes deeper, and choosing siding materials covers the system behind both.

Navy James Hardie lap siding with white trim on a Cape Cod home in Central Pennsylvania, installed by Fortress Siding & Roofing
James Hardie lap siding on a Cape Cod home.

How do you know the siding needs replacing, not repairing?

Replacement is usually the answer when the damage is widespread or the wall behind the siding is getting wet. Boards that are warped, cracked or loose in several places, soft spots near windows and doors, and moisture or mold showing up indoors all point that way. A single damaged section on otherwise sound siding can often be repaired.

Our guide to siding repair or full replacement walks through the call.

Want a straight answer on your home?

We will look at the house, tell you what it needs, and give you a detailed estimate. It is free and there is no pressure.

What affects the cost of a siding replacement?

The size of the home, the amount of trim and detail, how much old siding has to come off and the material you choose drive the price more than anything else. Every home is priced on its own, so we do not publish prices, and financing is available for qualified homeowners.

Our Lancaster County siding replacement cost guide explains each factor, and how to compare siding estimates shows why two quotes for the same house can be far apart.

How long does a siding replacement take?

A full-home James Hardie installation typically takes one to two weeks, depending on home size, trim work and weather. We strip one side at a time, and each section is weather-protected the same day. Cold alone does not stop the work; our winter installation guide has the detail.

How do you get a siding replacement estimate?

Call 717-864-6896 or use our contact page. Estimates are free, detailed and no-pressure. We serve ten Pennsylvania counties: York, Lancaster, Cumberland, Dauphin, Lebanon, Berks, Chester, Bucks, Montgomery and Delaware.

Common Questions

What does a full siding replacement include?

A full siding replacement includes removing the old siding, inspecting the wall sheathing, installing the weather-resistive barrier and flashing, installing the new siding and trim, and cleanup. If we find rot once the old siding is off, you see it and approve the repair first. We handle the permits.

Is James Hardie or vinyl siding the better choice?

Both are sound choices. James Hardie fiber cement costs more up front and suits character homes that want wide trim and deep shadow lines. Premium vinyl is the lower-cost, low-maintenance route. The house and the budget usually decide, and a free estimate can price both for your home.

How long does a siding replacement take?

A full-home James Hardie installation typically takes one to two weeks, depending on home size, trim work and weather. We strip one side at a time, and each section is weather-protected the same day.

Where does Fortress replace siding?

We replace siding in ten Pennsylvania counties from our base in Mountville: York, Lancaster, Cumberland, Dauphin, Lebanon, Berks, Chester, Bucks, Montgomery and Delaware. Call 717-864-6896 to confirm coverage for your address.

More answers on our FAQ page.

Get Your Free Estimate

No pressure. No obligation. Just a straight answer on what your project will take and what it'll cost.

Phone 717-864-6896
Hours Monday-Saturday, 7 AM-7 PM. Closed Sunday.
Service Area Based in Mountville, PA
Central & Southeastern Pennsylvania
Lesher Holdings shield logo A Lesher Holdings Company
📞 Call NowFree Estimate