★ 5.0 on Google (17 reviews)  |  Serving Central & Southeastern PA  |  Call 717-864-6896 for a Free Estimate
Roof replacement guide

Signs You Need a New Roof: What Pennsylvania Homeowners Can Check

The five signs you need a new roof are curling, cupping, or missing shingles; granules in your gutters; water stains on ceilings or in the attic; shingles that look faded, brittle, or patchy; and daylight through the roof boards in the attic. Most asphalt shingle roofs last 20 to 30 years, so a roof near 20 deserves a look even without symptoms. Fortress Siding & Roofing replaces roofs across Lancaster County and York County, PA, and a free inspection tells you whether yours needs replacing or has years left.

PA HIC #PA203681Fully insuredFree, detailed estimatesWe handle the permits

What are the signs you need a new roof?

The signs you need a new roof are curling or missing shingles, granules in the gutters, water stains on a ceiling or in the attic, faded or brittle shingles, and daylight through the roof boards. You can spot each one from the ground or from inside the house. The list below gives the five as we word them in our roofing FAQ for first-time homeowners.

  • Curling, cupping, or missing shingles — the shingle has lost its flexibility
  • Granules in your gutters — the protective surface is washing away
  • Water stains on ceilings or in the attic — water is already getting inside
  • Shingles that look faded, brittle, or patchy — UV has cooked the mat
  • Daylight through the roof boards in the attic — call someone today

One or two of these does not automatically mean a full replacement. It does mean the protective layer is breaking down somewhere. Age is the other clue. Most asphalt shingle roofs last 20 to 30 years, so a roof coming up on 20 years, or one whose age you do not know, deserves a look.

How urgent is each roof warning sign?

Urgency runs from "watch it" for a few granules in the gutters to "act today" for daylight through the roof boards. The table sorts the five signs by what each one means and how quickly to move.

Roof warning signs, what each one means and how urgent it is
SignWhat it meansHow urgent
Curling, cupping, or missing shinglesThe shingle has lost its flexibility. CertainTeed lists slight curling as normal aging, so judge by how much the shingles curl and how many do.This season. CertainTeed warns that a missing shingle can turn into a leak.
Granules in your guttersThe protective surface is washing away. Slight granule loss is normal aging, and a new roof sheds some during its first stage. Bald, dark patches on the shingles are not normal.Watch it while the shingles still look evenly covered. This season once you see bald patches.
Water stains on ceilings or in the atticWater is already getting inside, either through the roof or as condensation in the attic.This week. Wet decking rots, and rot spreads to the framing.
Shingles that look faded, brittle, or patchyUV has cooked the mat. The asphalt has hardened, and a brittle shingle cracks more easily.This season, sooner if you also see cracks.
Daylight through the roof boards in the atticThe roof deck has an opening. In a vented attic, light at the ridge vent or a roof vent is expected. Light through the boards is not.Today.

Treat the last column as a rule of thumb, not a diagnosis. Two signs together, or any one sign on a roof near 20 years old, make a stronger case for an inspection.

Daylight through the roof boards and fresh water stains should not wait, so have a roofer look promptly. We replace roofs and do not repair them. If the roof is also near the end of its 20 to 30 years, the question becomes replacement, and that is the work we do.

What makes asphalt shingles age and fail?

Asphalt shingles age because sun, heat and water slowly harden the asphalt and loosen the granules that protect it. CertainTeed, the manufacturer whose shingles we install, explains the process in The Life Cycle of Your Roof, a homeowner's guide linked from its article on when to replace a roof.

Asphalt carries oils that keep a shingle pliable. Over the years those oils rise to the surface and rain washes them away, while rooftop heat hardens the asphalt that remains. As the asphalt hardens, the granules start to break loose, the asphalt layers shrink, and the shingle edges begin to curl. A harder shingle is also a more brittle one, and that is when surface cracks can appear.

CertainTeed says the sun can raise rooftop temperatures 50 to 75 degrees Fahrenheit above the air temperature, and a summer shower can drop the surface 60 to 100 degrees almost at once. Each swing makes the roof deck expand and contract, and the shingles take that strain year after year. Pennsylvania winters add freeze-thaw cycles to the list.

CertainTeed describes three stages: an initial curing phase of rapid aging right after installation, a long middle stretch of slow aging, and the declining years, when aging speeds up again. The declining years are when homeowners normally start to think about replacement.

The same guide says a poorly ventilated attic usually holds more moisture, that heat shortens shingle life, and that moisture makes the roof deck move or deteriorate. It adds that blisters often appear when minimum ventilation requirements are not met.

What can you check safely from the ground?

From the ground you can check the shingles, the roofline and the visible flashing, and a pair of binoculars is the only tool you need. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) tells property owners to inspect from the ground or through upstairs windows and never to climb onto a roof. Walking on shingles is dangerous for you and can damage the roof surface.

ARMA recommends a check in spring and another in fall. Walk all the way around the house, look at every slope, and go down this list.

  1. Shingle edges. Look for shingles that curl or cup, and for gaps where a shingle is gone.
  2. Color and coverage. Look for dark, bald patches where the granules are gone and the asphalt shows.
  3. Cracks. Fine surface cracks come with age. CertainTeed says cracks that run through a shingle's reinforcement threaten the roof's waterproofing and need attention immediately.
  4. The roofline. CertainTeed says sagging can indicate trapped moisture or a weakened structure.
  5. Flashing. Look for gaps in the metal around the chimney, the vent pipes and any wall the roof meets. ARMA calls flashings the most vulnerable points on a roof.
  6. Gutters. You cannot see into a gutter from the lawn, so look for granules the next time the gutters are cleaned. CertainTeed says granules in the gutters mean the shingles may be deteriorating.
  7. Moss. Check the shaded, north-facing slopes first. ARMA says moss can lift or curl shingle edges and, in severe cases, cause moisture damage to the roof deck.

What can you check safely in the attic?

In the attic you can check the underside of the roof deck for water stains, wet insulation, mold and daylight, with nothing more than a flashlight. CertainTeed suggests making this check after a rain.

ENERGY STAR's attic guidance says to walk on joists or truss chords, not on exposed ceiling drywall or insulation, and to watch for sharp nails that stick through the roof deck. It also recommends a respirator or dust mask and an early start on hot days.

  • Stains on the wood. Dark marks on the underside of the deck or on the rafters mean water has been there. ARMA says to look most carefully at the flashing points, because flashings are where a roof is most vulnerable.
  • Wet insulation or mold. CertainTeed lists both among the things to look for after a rain.
  • Condensation. A stain is not always a roof leak. ARMA notes that in winter, in a cold attic, warm, moist air from the house condenses on the rafters, the nails and the underside of the deck, and that the water can corrode nails and rot wood.
  • Daylight. Stand still on a joist, switch off the flashlight and study the underside of the deck. ARMA says that in a vented attic you should see light at the ridge vent or at the vents near the top of the roof. Light through the boards anywhere else is the fifth sign on our list.
  • Vents that end in the attic. ARMA says no vent from inside the house should discharge into the attic. A bathroom fan duct that stops short of the outdoors is one example.

Want a straight answer on your home?

We will look at the house, tell you what it needs, and give you a detailed estimate. It is free and there is no pressure.

Which roof changes look bad but do not mean a new roof?

Dark streaks, a few granules in the gutters and slight edge curling look alarming, but all three can be normal aging on an asphalt shingle roof. CertainTeed's guide lists slight granule loss, curling and algae discoloration as normal aging, and it notes that even a one-year-old roof may look different from a new one.

  • Dark streaks. ARMA says brown or black streaks are often airborne algae, and it reports no scientific evidence that algae damages asphalt shingles. The problem is cosmetic.
  • Curling that comes and goes. CertainTeed says slight curling can look worse in cold weather and lie flat again as temperatures rise.

CertainTeed's list of wear beyond normal aging is short: blisters that have opened, cracking, and bald spots where the asphalt is exposed. Large bald areas put a shingle at risk of early failure, because UV rays now reach the asphalt directly.

ARMA also says never to scrub or pressure wash an asphalt shingle roof, because both can strip granules.

What does a roof inspection settle?

A roof inspection settles whether the wear you found is normal aging or the end of the roof's life. CertainTeed's guide points out that weathering noticed from a ladder may not be visible from the lawn or the driveway. A ground check narrows the question, and an inspection answers it.

Our inspection is free, and it answers three questions.

  • Replace now, or keep watching? We will tell you honestly whether you need a roof or the roof just needs watching.
  • How many layers must be removed? We tear off to the deck and never roof over old shingles, so the layer count affects the price.
  • What is the real number? A roof priced without a count of its layers is a guess, so the number comes after the inspection, in a free, detailed estimate with no pressure to decide on the spot.

The one thing no inspection can settle is the decking. It sits under the shingles, so we check it for rot and soft spots once the old roof is removed, and we replace anything soft.

Know one limit before you book: we replace roofs, and we do not repair them. A roof that needs only a fix is a job for a roofer who offers that work.

What should you do if your roof shows these signs?

If your roof shows any of the five signs, or is coming up on 20 years, get it inspected and get the answer in writing. Fortress Siding & Roofing is an owner-led company based in Mountville, and we replace roofs across Lancaster County, York County and eight nearby Pennsylvania counties.

Our roof replacement page explains the work: a full tear-off to the deck, CertainTeed architectural shingles, one to two days for most homes, and our 10-year workmanship guarantee from Fortress. To see what moves the price of a new roof, read our Lancaster County roof replacement cost guide.

When you are ready, book a roof inspection online or call 717-864-6896. The inspection is free, and there is no pressure to decide on the spot.

Common Questions

What are the signs you need a new roof?

The signs are curling, cupping, or missing shingles; granules in your gutters; water stains on ceilings or in the attic; shingles that look faded, brittle, or patchy; and daylight through the roof boards in the attic. One or two of these does not automatically mean a full replacement. It does mean the protective layer is breaking down somewhere, and an inspection shows how far along the roof is.

How long does an asphalt shingle roof last in Pennsylvania?

Most asphalt shingle roofs last 20 to 30 years. Where a roof lands in that span comes down to the grade of shingle and whether it was installed correctly. If your roof is coming up on 20 years, or you bought the house and do not know the roof's age, have it inspected before a ceiling stain makes the decision urgent.

Are granules in the gutters always a sign of a failing roof?

No, some granule loss is normal, even on a new roof. CertainTeed's homeowner guide lists slight granule loss as normal aging and says granules can shed during the curing phase right after installation. The concern is large bald areas where the asphalt shows, because UV rays then reach the asphalt directly and the shingle is at risk of early failure.

Do dark streaks on a roof mean it needs replacing?

No, dark streaks alone do not mean a roof needs replacing. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association says the streaks are often airborne algae and reports no scientific evidence that algae damages asphalt shingles. Moss is different: the association says it can lift or curl shingle edges and, in severe cases, cause moisture damage to the roof deck. Never scrub or pressure wash a shingle roof.

Is it safe to walk on my roof to check the shingles?

No, stay off the roof. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association says property owners should never climb onto a roof and should inspect from the ground or through upstairs windows, with binoculars. In the attic, ENERGY STAR says to walk on joists or truss chords, not on exposed ceiling drywall or insulation, and to watch for nails that stick through the roof deck.

What does a free roof inspection tell me?

A roof inspection tells you whether the roof needs replacing now or has years left. It is also how you get a real number, because a roof priced without a count of its layers is a guess. The estimate is free and detailed, with no pressure to decide on the spot. The decking is checked once the old shingles are removed. We replace roofs and do not repair them.

More answers on our FAQ page.

Get Your Free Estimate

No pressure. No obligation. Just a straight answer on what your project will take and what it'll cost.

Phone 717-864-6896
Hours Monday-Saturday, 7 AM-7 PM. Closed Sunday.
Service Area Based in Mountville, PA
Central & Southeastern Pennsylvania
Lesher Holdings shield logo A Lesher Holdings Company
📞 Call NowFree Estimate