★ 5.0 on Google (17 reviews)  |  Serving Central & Southeastern PA  |  Call 717-864-6896 for a Free Estimate
Roofing cost guide

What Affects the Cost of a Roof Replacement in Lancaster County, PA?

The cost of a roof replacement in Lancaster County, PA depends on the roof's size and pitch, the layers that have to be removed, the condition of the decking and the shingle you choose. A free inspection and a detailed, no-pressure estimate from Fortress Siding & Roofing are how you get a real number for your home.

PA HIC #PA203681Fully insuredFree, detailed estimatesWe handle the permits

Why does the cost of a new roof vary so much in Lancaster County?

The cost of a new roof varies because no two roofs call for the same work. We replace asphalt shingle roofs with a full tear-off to the deck, which is the only way we replace a roof. We do not roof over old shingles.

A small roof with a gentle pitch, one layer of shingles and sound decking costs less to replace. A large, steep roof with two layers, several valleys and soft decking costs more.

Anyone who prices a roof without getting on it, or without asking how many layers it carries, is guessing. This guide walks through each item that moves the price, so you can read any estimate line by line.

What changes the price of a roof replacement?

Eight things change the price of a roof replacement: roof size, pitch, the layers to remove, the decking, flashing details, ventilation, shingle grade and disposal. Most of them can be measured or counted during an inspection. The decking is the exception, because nobody can judge it fully until the old roof is gone.

Roof replacement cost drivers and their effect on price
Cost driverWhy it mattersEffect on priceWhen it is known
Roof sizeShingles, underlayment, labor and disposal all scale with areaRises with every added squareAt the inspection
PitchA steeper roof has more surface and slows the crewRises as the slope steepensAt the inspection
Layers to removeEach layer adds labor and disposal weightRises with each extra layerAt the inspection
DeckingSoft or rotten wood is replaced before underlaymentRises only if damage is foundOnce the old roof is removed
Valleys, walls and penetrationsEach one needs flashing, cutting and sealingRises with the countAt the inspection
VentilationIntake or exhaust vents may need to be addedRises if vents are addedAt the inspection
Shingle gradeHeavier, multi-layer shingles cost more than basic onesRises with a higher-priced lineWhen you choose
Dumpster and disposalDebris is charged by weightRises with size and layersAt the inspection

How do roof size and pitch change the price?

Roof size and pitch set the base of the price, because they decide how much material is installed and how long the crew works. Roofers measure in squares. The National Roofing Contractors Association defines a square as 100 square feet of roof area, so a roof with 2,000 square feet of surface is 20 squares.

Pitch adds surface that a floor plan hides. A roof that rises 6 inches for every 12 inches of run has about 12 percent more surface than the level area beneath it. A roof that rises 12 inches for every 12 has about 41 percent more.

Pitch also slows the work. A steep roof takes longer to work safely, and time is part of the price.

Why do extra layers and bad decking raise the price?

Extra layers and bad decking raise the price because both add labor and material that a single-layer roof with a sound deck does not need. Every layer has to be stripped, loaded into the dumpster and disposed of by weight. A roof with two layers of shingles takes longer to strip and puts more weight in the dumpster than a roof with one.

We do not roof over old shingles, so every layer comes off every roof we replace. That is how the deck comes into view. The deck is the structural layer that carries the roofing, such as plywood or wood planks.

With the roof open, we check the decking for rot and soft spots and replace anything soft before the new underlayment is installed. Replacing decking adds material and labor, and it can add time to the usual one to two days.

Decking is the one line nobody can price from the driveway. A written estimate should say what happens if the crew finds soft decking: how it is measured, what each sheet or square foot costs and who approves the added work. Ask every contractor for that number before you sign.

How do flashing, ventilation and shingle grade affect the cost?

Flashing, ventilation and shingle grade affect the cost through the number of details on your roof and the product you pick. The roofing trade uses flashing to mean the components that seal a roof at its edges, walls, valleys and penetrations, the places where the shingles stop or are interrupted. Each valley, chimney and pipe adds cutting and sealing, so a roof with many of them costs more than a plain gable roof of the same size.

Check how each estimate handles the flashing where a roof meets a wall. The estimate should say which flashing is new and which is being reused.

Ventilation is the next line to check. CertainTeed describes proper attic ventilation as a balanced system of air intake at the eaves or soffits and air exhaust at or near the ridge. If a roof is short on either one, adding vents adds cost, and the estimate should name the vents being installed.

Shingle grade is the part you choose. CertainTeed sorts asphalt shingles into strip, dimensional and luxury types. Strip shingles are a single layer and generally weigh and cost less than the others. Dimensional shingles, also called architectural or laminate shingles, are two or more layers fused together.

We install CertainTeed architectural shingles. A higher-priced shingle raises the total.

Who handles the permits, the dumpster and the disposal?

We handle the permits. We also handle the dumpster, the hauling and the cleanup as part of the job, so you are not coordinating a container and a crew.

Disposal still shows up in the price, because its cost follows the weight of the debris. A second layer of shingles means more weight in the dumpster, so it raises the disposal cost.

Want a straight answer on your home?

We will look at the house, tell you what it needs, and give you a detailed estimate. It is free and there is no pressure.

What should a written roof estimate include?

A written roof estimate should include every step of the job and every price that could change, not just a shingle price. Use this list to compare estimates side by side:

  • The measured roof area and the number of layers being removed.
  • Tear-off, disposal and cleanup, including the dumpster.
  • The price for replacing soft decking, by the sheet or by the square foot.
  • Underlayment and flashing, with new and reused flashing named.
  • Any ventilation work.
  • The shingle manufacturer and product line.
  • Who handles the permits.
  • The workmanship warranty term and the contractor's Pennsylvania registration number.
  • The total price, the deposit and the payment schedule.

When two estimates are far apart, compare the scope before the totals. One may leave out decking, flashing or disposal that the other includes. We are a registered Pennsylvania Home Improvement Contractor, #PA203681.

Can you finance a roof replacement?

Yes, financing is available for qualified homeowners. We do not publish rates or terms on this site, so ask about current financing options when you schedule your free estimate.

How do you get a real price for your roof?

You get a real price from a free inspection and the detailed estimate that follows. A roof priced without anyone getting on it, or without a count of its layers, is a guess. Our estimate is free and detailed, with no pressure to decide on the spot.

Our roof replacement page covers the full sequence, the CertainTeed shingles we install and our 10-year workmanship guarantee. Most replacements take one to two days, weather permitting. Our guide to what to expect on roof replacement day covers the day itself.

To start, book a roof inspection online or call 717-864-6896. We are based in Mountville and replace roofs across Lancaster County, from Columbia and Millersville to Lititz and Manheim Township. If your roof has years left, we will tell you that honestly.

Common Questions

What affects the cost of a roof replacement in Lancaster County, PA?

The cost of a roof replacement in Lancaster County depends on the size and pitch of the roof, the number of old layers to remove, the condition of the decking, the valleys and penetrations that need flashing, and the shingle you choose. A free inspection and a detailed, no-pressure estimate are how you get a real number for your home.

Why does a steep roof cost more to replace?

A steep roof costs more because it has more surface to cover and takes longer to work safely. A roof that rises 12 inches for every 12 inches of run has about 41 percent more surface than the level area beneath it. Working safely on that slope takes time, and time is part of the price.

Can a roofer price rotten decking before the old roof is removed?

No, nobody can price rotten decking for certain until the old roofing is removed. The deck is hidden under the shingles and the underlayment. We tear every roof down to the deck, check it for rot and soft spots, and replace anything soft. Ask each contractor to write the price for replacement decking into the estimate before you sign.

Can you finance a roof replacement?

Yes, financing is available for qualified homeowners. We do not publish rates or terms on this site, so ask about current financing options when you schedule your free, detailed estimate. The estimate itself costs nothing, and there is no pressure to decide on the spot.

Why do two roof estimates for the same house differ so much?

Two estimates can differ widely because they do not describe the same work. One may count a single layer of old shingles, reuse old flashing, or leave decking and disposal unpriced, while the other includes all of them. Compare the scope line by line before you compare the totals, and ask each contractor to price the same list.

More answers on our FAQ page.

Get Your Free Estimate

No pressure. No obligation. Just a straight answer on what your project will take and what it'll cost.

Phone 717-864-6896
Hours Monday-Saturday, 7 AM-7 PM. Closed Sunday.
Service Area Based in Mountville, PA
Central & Southeastern Pennsylvania
Lesher Holdings shield logo A Lesher Holdings Company
📞 Call NowFree Estimate