Architectural Shingles vs Metal Roofing in Pennsylvania
For a Pennsylvania home, architectural asphalt shingles cost less up front and a metal roof lasts longer. Asphalt shingle roofs last 20 to 30 years, while InterNACHI lists metal at 40 to 80 years. Fortress Siding & Roofing installs CertainTeed architectural shingles across Lancaster and York counties; metal roofing is not on our list of services.
Is an architectural shingle roof or a metal roof the better fit for a Pennsylvania home?
Neither roof is the better fit for every home: architectural asphalt shingles cost less up front, and metal lasts longer. The right pick depends mostly on your budget and on how long you plan to own the house.
First, where we stand: we install CertainTeed architectural asphalt shingles. Metal roofing is not on our list of services, so nothing here is a pitch for metal, and we have tried not to make it a pitch against metal either.
Every figure below names its source. Several metal figures come from the Metal Roofing Alliance (MRA), an industry group whose network includes metal roofing manufacturers and contractors, and the shingle ratings come from CertainTeed, a shingle manufacturer. Weigh each number with that in mind.
For product ratings we use two examples: CertainTeed's Landmark, which CertainTeed calls a prototypical dimensional shingle (its term for architectural), and one steel standing-seam panel made by Metal Sales. Other products carry other ratings, so read the data sheet for the product named in your own quote.
| Factor | Architectural asphalt shingles | Metal roofing | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expected life | 20 to 30 years (InterNACHI lists 30) | 40 to 80 years | InterNACHI life expectancy chart |
| Weight per 100 square feet | 211 to 225 lb (CertainTeed Landmark) | 94 to 138 lb (one steel standing-seam panel, 26 and 24 gauge) | CertainTeed Landmark data sheet; Metal Sales Vertical Seam data sheet |
| Snow and ice | Waterproofing shingle underlayment in areas with eave icing | Smooth surface sheds snow; snow guards control the release | CertainTeed Landmark data sheet; MRA snow and ice page |
| Rain noise | The baseline for MRA's comparison | As quiet as asphalt when properly installed, per MRA | MRA noise article |
| Wind rating | ASTM D3161 Class F and ASTM D7158 Class H, the top class in each test (Landmark) | Gusts of up to 140 mph for a quality system, per MRA | CertainTeed Landmark data sheet; MRA wind page |
| Hail impact rating (UL 2218; Class 4 is the top class) | Class 3 at time of manufacture (Landmark) | Class 4 (Metal Sales Vertical Seam); Class 4 for the majority of metal roofing, per MRA | Both data sheets; MRA hail page |
| Fire rating (Class A is the top class) | Class A (Landmark) | Class A (Metal Sales Vertical Seam) | Both data sheets; ARMA test standards page |
How long do architectural shingles and metal roofs last?
A metal roof lasts longer: most asphalt shingle roofs last 20 to 30 years, and metal is listed at 40 to 80 years. That metal range comes from the life expectancy chart published by InterNACHI, a home inspectors' association. The same chart lists architectural asphalt at 30 years and three-tab asphalt at 20.
CertainTeed, whose shingles we install, says metal roofs can last 50 years or longer. MRA tells homeowners to count on 30 to 50-plus years.
InterNACHI adds that roof life depends on local weather, design, material quality and maintenance, and that its figures are guidelines, not guarantees. Where a shingle roof lands between 20 and 30 years comes down to the grade of shingle and whether it was installed correctly.
What affects the cost of a metal roof compared with asphalt shingles?
The material and the roof itself drive the cost, and asphalt shingles cost less up front than metal. CertainTeed says asphalt shingles are less expensive than most other roofing options and that metal roofing is not inexpensive.
On a shingle roof, the price follows the size and pitch of the roof, the layers already on it and the shingle you choose. Our Lancaster County roof replacement cost guide covers those factors.
Metal comes as shingles, tiles and vertical panels in steel, aluminum, copper and zinc, so only a written quote from a metal installer counts for your house. For a shingle roof, our estimate is free, detailed and no-pressure.
Does a metal roof recoup more of its cost at resale than shingles?
No, a metal roof recoups a smaller share of its cost at sale than an asphalt shingle roof, according to Zonda's 2025 Cost vs. Value report. The report models one defined job: tear off the old roofing and install 3,000 square feet of new roofing on a hip roof that has two skylights. In Harrisburg, it estimates that the shingle roof recoups 62.6 percent of its cost and the standing-seam metal roof 47.5 percent. In York the figures are 60.7 percent for shingles and 43.8 percent for metal.
The report's shingle job specifies fiberglass asphalt shingles and does not say whether they are architectural, so read the comparison as asphalt shingles against standing-seam metal. The resale figures are estimates from a Zonda survey of more than 6,000 Realtors, not sale records, as the report's methodology page explains.
© 2025 Zonda Media, a Delaware Corporation. Complete data from the Remodeling 2025 Cost vs. Value Report can be downloaded free at www.costvsvalue.com.
The report has no Lancaster entry, so Harrisburg and York are the nearest Pennsylvania markets it covers. As of November 2026, the 2025 edition is the newest one on the publisher's site. Our post on siding and resale value explains how to read the report.
Is a metal roof heavier than a shingle roof?
No, metal is the lighter of the two. CertainTeed's Landmark data sheet lists that shingle at 211 to 225 lb per 100 square feet, depending on the plant. A Metal Sales data sheet for one steel standing-seam panel lists 0.94 to 1.38 lb per square foot across 26 and 24 gauge, which is 94 to 138 lb per 100 square feet. MRA's shorthand is that metal weighs half as much as asphalt.
MRA adds that metal is light enough that it can often go right over an old asphalt roof. Our shingle replacements are always a full tear-off, because a second layer adds dead weight to the framing and hides rotten decking that should have been found. Whichever material you choose, ask whether the old roof comes off first.
How do shingles and metal handle Pennsylvania snow and ice?
Metal sheds snow from its smooth surface and shingles rely on a waterproofing underlayment where eaves ice, according to the two industries, while the National Weather Service's ice dam advice centers on the attic. Harrisburg's normal snowfall is 29.9 inches a year, by the National Weather Service's 1991–2020 normals. Its normal January high is 39 degrees Fahrenheit, which is above freezing.
The National Weather Service explains that ice dams form when roof snow melts during the day and refreezes overnight. After several days of those cycles, the water can work its way under the shingles. The agency says most experts put attic insulation at R-30 or more, with R-38 preferable in northern climates, and it calls good airflow from the soffits to the roof vents essential.
MRA says the smooth surface of several metal roofing styles encourages snow to shed and minimizes ice damming. The trade-off is the slide itself, so MRA points homeowners to snow guards that control the release above people, vehicles and landscaping. On a shingle roof, CertainTeed's data sheet calls for a waterproofing shingle underlayment in areas where icing along the eaves can cause water backup.
We do not air seal ceilings or blow attic insulation, so the attic side is a job for an insulation contractor. Our post on fascia, soffit and gutters explains why ice dams are an attic problem.
Want a straight answer on your home?
We will look at the house, tell you what it needs, and give you a detailed estimate. It is free and there is no pressure.
Is a metal roof louder than shingles in the rain?
A properly installed metal roof is about as quiet as a shingle roof, according to MRA. MRA says the sound depends on the roof deck, the insulation and the installation, not only on the roofing. It adds that metal over a solid deck, with proper insulation and fasteners, greatly reduces sound.
MRA treats a noisy metal roof as a warning sign: too few fasteners, loose fasteners or too little insulation. All of this is an industry group's statement, not an independent sound measurement, so take it as the metal industry's position.
How do the wind and hail ratings compare?
On our two example products, the shingle holds the top class in both shingle wind tests and the metal panel holds the higher hail impact class. For wind, the Landmark data sheet lists ASTM D3161 Class F and ASTM D7158 Class H. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) describes each as the highest class in its test.
MRA says a quality metal roof system can withstand gusts of up to 140 mph. The Metal Sales data sheet lists a different wind test (UL 580 uplift), so the two wind figures cannot be compared directly.
For hail, both industries use the UL 2218 test. ARMA describes it as steel balls dropped from 12 to 20 feet onto the roofing, with Class 4 the highest of four classes. CertainTeed lists Landmark at Class 3, and the Metal Sales panel is listed at Class 4. MRA says the majority of metal roofing earns Class 4, and it acknowledges that any roof type can pick up cosmetic marks in a severe hailstorm.
These are laboratory ratings for products, and we cite them as nothing more. We replace roofs; we do not do storm or insurance work.
Which roof makes sense for your home?
Architectural shingles make sense when up-front cost matters most, and metal makes sense when you plan to stay long enough to use its longer life. Three questions help settle it.
- How long will you own the house? The longer you plan to stay, the more the extra years of metal are worth.
- What can the budget carry? Metal costs more up front than asphalt shingles.
- How well is the attic insulated and vented? The National Weather Service points to attic insulation and airflow as the way to limit ice dams.
If metal is where you land, you will need a contractor that installs it. Our roofing work is architectural asphalt shingles.
How do you get a price for an architectural shingle roof?
You get a real price by having the roof inspected and measured, and our inspection is free. Fortress Siding & Roofing is an owner-led company in Mountville, and we replace roofs across Lancaster County, York County and eight nearby Pennsylvania counties.
Every roof replacement is a full tear-off to the deck with CertainTeed architectural shingles, and it comes with the 10-year workmanship guarantee from Fortress. You can book a roof inspection online or call 717-864-6896. If your roof has years left, we will tell you that honestly.
Common Questions
Is a metal roof worth the extra cost in Pennsylvania?
A metal roof is worth the extra cost mainly when you plan to stay in the home long enough to use its longer life. InterNACHI lists metal at 40 to 80 years and architectural shingles at 30. At resale, Zonda's 2025 Cost vs. Value report estimates that a Harrisburg shingle roof recoups 62.6 percent of its cost and a metal roof 47.5 percent.
How long do architectural shingles last compared with a metal roof?
Most asphalt shingle roofs last 20 to 30 years, and metal roofs are listed at 40 to 80 years. InterNACHI's life expectancy chart puts architectural asphalt at 30 years and metal at 40 to 80. CertainTeed, a shingle manufacturer, says metal can last 50 years or longer. Local weather, material quality, installation and maintenance all move the real number.
Does Fortress Siding & Roofing install metal roofing?
No, metal roofing is not on our list of services. Fortress Siding & Roofing installs CertainTeed architectural asphalt shingles. Every roof replacement we do is a full tear-off to the deck, and it comes with our 10-year workmanship guarantee. If you decide on metal, look for a contractor that installs that material.
Are metal roofs noisy when it rains?
A properly installed metal roof is about as quiet as an asphalt roof, according to the Metal Roofing Alliance. The industry group says sound depends on the roof deck, insulation and installation, and that metal over a solid deck with proper insulation and fasteners greatly reduces sound. That is an industry statement, not an independent sound measurement, so treat it as the metal industry's position.
Do metal roofs prevent ice dams?
A metal roof may reduce ice dams, but none of the sources we cite says it prevents them. The Metal Roofing Alliance says the smooth surface of several metal roofing styles sheds snow and minimizes ice damming. The National Weather Service explains that ice dams form when roof snow melts and refreezes, and it points to attic insulation and airflow from the soffits to the roof vents.
More answers on our FAQ page.
Get Your Free Estimate
No pressure. No obligation. Just a straight answer on what your project will take and what it'll cost.
Central & Southeastern Pennsylvania